Austin New Construction vs. Resale Homes: Which Costs Less?

Austin Suburbs Alisha & Matt • November 14, 2026

In Hutto last month, 7 out of every 10 homes that closed were brand new. A year ago, it was 4 out of 10. Pflugerville went from 1 in 4 to nearly half. And the typical new home in Austin sold for about $525,000, roughly $165,000 less than last year.

In three markets on our map, a new home now costs less than a used one, even per square foot. We pulled every October sale and lined the new homes up against the resale ones to show you where the deals are and where the builders are holding firm. We also picked the one new home in each suburb we'd go see first, based on price, space, taxes, time on market, and location.

The numbers tell you where the market is. They don't tell you what to buy. That part is a conversation with us. Whether you're moving in 10 days or 10 months, it's never too early to book a call and go over your price range and your shortlist. People just like you ask us every week where the builders are dealing, and for our clients, we track exactly that.

Table of Contents

Hutto: New Homes Under $300,000

Hutto is the only suburb on our list where the typical new home sells for under $300,000. In October, that number landed at about $298,000. A year ago, it was almost $365,000. That's $67,000 less, or about an 18% drop.

Roughly half of that comes from smaller homes. The typical new home sold went from about 2,170 square feet to nearly 1,900. The other half is price per square foot, which fell from $177 to $155. And $155 is the lowest on our list. Used homes in Hutto ran $174 a square foot, so new came in about $17,000 under the typical used home, which sold for $315,000.

Builder reps have told us that the builders are starting to build smaller on purpose for more affordable houses. There is a trade for builders though. A typical new home took 67 days to sell, up from about 45. Used homes sold in 36 days, so new homes are sitting nearly twice as long. That gives buyers room. A builder with finished homes and a slow month tends to start to negotiate. Or call us and say, make me a deal.

Windfield Park alone sold 25 new homes. That's nearly 4 in 10 of Hutto's new sales and the most of any neighborhood on our map. Flora added 10 more and Firefly Point sold 8. If you are interested in Flora, we actually made a tour about Flora.

Hutto went from less than half new to more than 2/3 new in 12 months. That's the biggest shift on our map. And if you watch our videos about Hutto from a year ago to now, you understand why we love Hutto so much and showing Hutto. We got our clients into some Hutto houses. Go Hippos!

Prairie Winds: Our Hutto Pick

In Hutto, our pick is in Prairie Winds . Trophy Signature Homes has a home at just under $410,000 with 4 bedrooms, 3 baths, and about 2,650 square feet. That's $155 a square foot. New homes in Hutto sold for $155 a square foot and used homes for $174, so it lands right at the new home average as well as under used.

Taxes run 2.16%, around $740 a month before exemptions, plus a $55 monthly HOA. It's been listed for about 2 months. It ties on score with a home in Flora that costs $422,000 but carries a 2.96% tax rate. That's about $300 more a month in taxes.

The catch is choice. Prairie Winds has 26 new homes listed, so you'll want to see more than one. That same inventory is why builders in Prairie Winds are often willing to talk. Make me a deal!

Pflugerville: New Home Sales Jump 58%

Pflugerville sold 41 new homes in October, up from 26. That's 58% more. Prices fell hard. The typical new home sold for $385,000. A year ago, almost $500,000. That's about 23% lower.

Again, part of it is size. The typical new home went from nearly 2,500 square feet to about 2,200, and price per square foot dropped from $211 to $189. Used homes had it rougher. The typical used home sold for $345,000, down nearly 14%. Do you think it just needed a good coat of paint? Maybe. Only 49 used homes sold against 76 a year ago. So new went from a quarter of the market to 46% of the Pflugerville market.

Against used, new still carries a premium, about $40,000 more and $189 a square foot against $167. Builders are feeling it in selling time. A typical new home took 89 days, up from 67 days. Used homes sold in about 54 days.

Lisso and The Trails at Carmel led with 10 new sales each. Meadowlark Preserve sold 9. And be on the lookout because we will be doing tours of The Trails at Carmel and Lisso. A builder watching a home sit past about 3 months usually gets more flexible. Past about 6, a lot more flexible.

Pflugerville has 87 new homes listed for sale. The Trails at Carmel has 19 of those 87. That's about 2 months of supply. The typical new home has been listed 92 days.

Lakeside Meadows: Our Pflugerville Pick

In Pflugerville, it's Lakeside Meadows . Meritage Homes has a 4-bed, 3-bath home with just over 3,000 square feet for just under $465,000. That's $154 a square foot. New homes in Pflugerville sold for $189 a square foot and used homes sold for $167. This one is well under both.

Lake Pflugerville is close by with kayaking, paddleboarding, and waterside trails. Good news if the dog or dogs need a walk. Taxes are about 2.19%, about $850 a month before exemptions. HOA dues are $950 a year. It's been on the market for about 4 and a half months in total. That's usually when a builder starts returning calls a lot faster.

4 bedrooms means the home office doesn't have to be the dining room table.

Georgetown: New Homes Below Resale Prices

Georgetown still sells the most new homes on our map. 60 sold in October, down from 85 last year. The typical new home sold for about $435,000, down about 10%. But builders did move them faster. A typical new home took 80 days to sell, down from 103.

Price per square foot slipped from $206 to $194. The homes got a little smaller as well. From about 2,600 square feet to 2,500. Here's what surprised us. New homes in Georgetown now cost less than used ones. $435,000 against $449,000. And price per square foot, $194 for new against $205 for used.

Used sales actually rose here. 102 sold, up from 91. It's the only market on our map where more used homes sold than a year ago. Now that makes more sense because Georgetown is a very desirable place. More established neighborhoods, a lot of times with the large trees and shade, are more desirable.

Woodfield Preserve led new sales with 9. Wolf Ranch and Nolina sold 7 each. And Georgetown holds almost half of all the new homes listed for sale across our 5 suburbs. 248 of 518. Parkside on the River has 41 homes listed. That's 17% of the suburb's new inventory.

Georgetown has about 3 months of supply. The typical new home has been listed about 135 days. That's more than 4 months. A builder with a home listed for 4 months is usually more flexible than one with a home listed for 4 weeks.

Nolina: Our Georgetown Pick

In Georgetown, Nolina , and guess what? We have clients who bought in Nolina. And we did a tour on it. Check out our video. Shout out to Caitlin. She's the director of fun there and she is awesome. She plans some amazing activities at Nolina.

Weston Homes has a 5-bedroom, 4-bath home with nearly 3,800 square feet for under $680,000. If you want like a luxury feel, Weston Homes is the way to go. And the best part, it's $179 a square foot. New homes in Georgetown sold for $194 and used homes sold for $205. You're under both, and this one has a 3-car garage, and it sits on just under a 5th of an acre. That's a real yard by today's standards.

Taxes run 2.48%, around $1,405 a month before exemptions. HOA dues are around $277 a quarter. It's been listed about 3 months, and it scored the highest of any home on our list this month. It's also our most expensive pick, but Georgetown's new home sales fell 29%, so a builder with a home this size has reason to listen, or to call us.

Round Rock: New Homes Carry a Premium

Round Rock goes in the complete other direction. New sales fell from 18 to 12. And that's really no surprise though, because Round Rock is a lot more established than the other suburbs we cover. So there's a lot less new inventory. There's basically no room to build. That's the reason why.

The typical new home in Round Rock sold for $492,000, which is up 12%. But it's a small group and the homes were bigger, about 3,000 square feet against about 2,600. New homes took 96 days to sell, up from about 63. Used homes took 38.

Used homes in Round Rock sold for $385,000, down 7%. So new carries about a $107,000 premium. Round Rock has 32 new homes listed for sale. That's about 3 months of supply. The typical new home has been listed 100 days.

About 1 in 10 sales in Round Rock are new. A lot more established than other suburbs covered. A lot less new inventory, basically no room to build.

University Heights: Our Round Rock Pick

In Round Rock, it's University Heights . Scott Felder has a full 5-bedroom, 4-bath home with about 2,860 square feet for under $522,000. That's $182 a square foot. New homes in Round Rock sold for $225 and used homes for $192, so it sits well under both.

Taxes are 1.86%, the lowest on our list, around $810 a month before exemptions, and the HOA dues there are also $50 a month. Fiber internet runs into the homes. The community has a pool with a spray pad, a covered pavilion, a playground, and walking trails.

The catch is the lot. It's about an 8th of an acre, so it's got a really small backyard. It's been listed about 3 months and 9 homes are listed there. That usually means there's room to talk.

Manor: The Widest Premium Gap

In Manor, our hometown, there were 12 new home sales, down from 19. The typical new home sold for roughly $398,000, about 2% higher than last year. And it sold faster, 75 days against 112 days a year ago.

Used homes in Manor sold for around $282,000. That's $152 a square foot, the lowest on our list. So the new home premium in Manor is about $115,000. That's the widest gap on the map.

Manor has 77 new homes listed for sale. Carillon has 25 of those 77. Manor has the loosest supply at about 4 months. The typical new home has been listed 78 days. Keep in mind, Manor and Round Rock sell so few new homes that those numbers can swing quickly, and this is a snapshot of today.

Carillon: Our Manor Pick

In Manor, our hometown, the pick is Carillon . MI Homes has a 5-bedroom, 3-bath home with about 2,850 square feet for under $400,000. It's about 8 minutes away, so give us a call. We'll definitely take a look. That is $140 a square foot, the lowest on our list. New homes in Manor sold for $180 a square foot and used homes for $152.

Carillon has a beautiful amenity center with a pool, a splash area, 2 dog parks, trails all around the area, a pond, and a plaza set up for food trucks. And if you want to know more about Carillon, watch our Carillon tour and all of our Manor tours. They're awesome.

Taxes run 2.63%, around $875 a month before exemptions. HOA dues are $50. It's been listed about 7 weeks and we already toured the whole community because we like you. The tax rate is the catch. Lagos, another top scorer in Manor, runs 2.36%, so that monthly number is worth comparing. We actually toured Lagos's neighbor, Lagos Reserve. It's the newer section. Check out that video, it's pretty awesome.

Austin: The $165,000 Year-Over-Year Price Difference

Now the comparison point, Austin. New home sales fell from 83 to 65. The typical new home sold for $525,000, down from $690,000. That's nearly 24% lower. Now, if you read the headlines, oh my gosh, Austin fell. But again, they're being lazy and they're not digging down to the facts. It's not nearly as big of a deal as some people are making it out to be.

And again, part of that is size. The typical new home went from about 2,650 square feet to about 2,300. And price per square foot fell from $266 to $231. Used homes in Austin went the opposite way. The typical used home sold for $600,000, up 2%. And I wonder why that is. Because Austin is a very desirable place to be. It's actually the only market on our map where used home prices went up.

So a new home in Austin costs about $75,000 less than a used one. That's the biggest gap we found. And per square foot, $231 for new against $277 for used. In Austin, it's about 1 in 9 sales are new.

Which Suburb Is Right for You?

Put it all together, new costs less than used in Austin, Georgetown, and Hutto. And new still carries a premium in Round Rock, Pflugerville, and Manor.

Across our 5 suburbs, 189 new homes sold in October. A year ago, that was 176. Used homes went the other way. 350 sold last October. This October, 307. So new sales rose 7% and used sales fell 12%. And since we specialize in new construction, that's what we love to hear.

But the gain wasn't spread evenly. Hutto went from 28 new home sales to 64, more than double. And Pflugerville climbed from 26 to 41. Georgetown still sells the most new homes. But it dropped from 85 to 60. And if you wait till next month, we have some news about Georgetown. Manor and Round Rock each sold 12. That's a small group, so read those 2 as a direction, not a verdict.

Now look at how much of each market is brand new. In Austin, it's about 1 in 9. Round Rock, about 1 in 10. In Georgetown and Manor, roughly a third. In Pflugerville, 46%. And in Hutto, 70%. A year ago, it was only 44%.

Choose Hutto if you want the lowest price per square foot on our map and a typical new home under $300,000. New homes are sitting nearly twice as long as used, which gives you room to negotiate. Prairie Winds has 26 of Hutto's 74 listings, so you'll have choices. About 1 month of supply means inventory is tight, but builders with finished homes and slow months tend to start to negotiate.

Choose Pflugerville if you want to be part of a market where new home sales jumped 58% and nearly half of all sales are brand new. New still carries about a $40,000 premium over used, but a builder watching a home sit past about 3 months usually gets more flexible. Lake Pflugerville is close by with kayaking, paddleboarding, and waterside trails.

Choose Georgetown if you want the most new home inventory on our map and a typical new home that now costs less than a used one. Georgetown holds almost half of all the new homes listed for sale across our 5 suburbs. The typical new home has been listed about 135 days, which is more than 4 months. A builder with a home listed for 4 months is usually more flexible than one with a home listed for 4 weeks. More established neighborhoods with large trees and shade are more desirable.

Choose Round Rock if you want a lot more established neighborhoods and basically no room to build. New carries about a $107,000 premium, but taxes are the lowest on our list at 1.86%. About 1 in 10 sales are new, so you're buying into a market with a lot less new inventory.

Choose Manor if you want the lowest price per square foot on used homes at $152 and the loosest supply at about 4 months. New carries the widest premium gap at about $115,000, but new homes are selling faster than they were a year ago. The tax rate is the catch. Lagos runs 2.36%, so that monthly number is worth comparing to Carillon at 2.63%.

Choose Austin if you want a new home that costs about $75,000 less than a used one. That's the biggest gap we found. And per square foot, $231 for new against $277 for used. Used home prices went up 2%, the only market on our map where that happened. Austin is a very desirable place to be.

Conclusion: What This Means for Buyers

New homes took over Hutto and Pflugerville at 70% and 46% of sales. In Austin, Georgetown, and Hutto, new homes now cost less than used ones, even per square foot. In Round Rock, Pflugerville, and Manor, new still carries a premium, and Georgetown holds almost half of all new homes listed.

Every month we score every new home for sale in our 5 suburbs. Price, space, taxes, time on market, and location. We only look at new construction inside a price range for each suburb. A market update tells you what happened to everyone else last month. It doesn't tell you what to offer on the house you actually want, and that's where we come in.

Numbers tell you where the market is. They don't tell you what to buy. That part is actually a conversation with us. Scan the QR code on screen or book a call through the link in the description or on our website. You can call, text, or email us. We answer all those ourselves because we like you.

Everything we just showed you, the builder already knows. The sales rep in the model home knows it too. That rep works for the builder. That's why you want us on your side. We know the market, we know the builders, and we're looking out for your best interest. And the builders know us. So call, text, or email us before you visit that first model home.

FAQ: Austin New vs. Resale Homes

Where do new homes cost less than resale in the Austin area?

In October, new homes cost less than used ones in Austin, Georgetown, and Hutto. In Austin, the typical new home sold for $525,000 against $600,000 for used. In Georgetown, $435,000 for new against $449,000 for used. In Hutto, $298,000 for new against $315,000 for used. New also costs less per square foot in all three markets.

Why did Austin new home prices drop so much year over year?

The typical new home in Austin sold for $525,000, down from $690,000 a year ago. That's nearly 24% lower. But roughly half of that comes from smaller homes. The typical new home went from about 2,650 square feet to about 2,300. The other half is price per square foot, which fell from $266 to $231. It's not nearly as big of a deal as some headlines make it out to be.

Which Austin suburb has the lowest price per square foot for new homes?

Hutto has the lowest price per square foot for new homes at $155. That's lower than used homes in Hutto at $174 a square foot. Our Hutto pick in Prairie Winds is $155 a square foot, which lands right at the new home average and under used. Manor has the lowest price per square foot for used homes at $152.

How long are new homes sitting on the market in the Austin suburbs?

In Georgetown, a typical new home has been listed about 135 days. In Round Rock, 100 days. In Hutto, about 97 days. In Pflugerville, 92 days. And in Manor, 78 days. A builder with a home listed for 4 months is usually more flexible than one with a home listed for 4 weeks. A builder watching a home sit past about 3 months usually gets more flexible. Past about 6 months, a lot more flexible.

What is months of supply and why does it matter?

Months of supply tells you how long the current inventory could last based on recent sales. We take the homes listed and divide them by how many new homes sell each month. We use the last 3 months of sales so one odd month doesn't skew it. Hutto comes out around 1 month, the tightest on our map. Pflugerville is about 2 months. Round Rock and Georgetown are about 3. Manor is the loosest at about 4 months. Tighter supply usually means less room to negotiate. Looser supply usually means more room.

How do you choose your top new home picks each month?

Every month we score every new home for sale in our 5 suburbs. Price, space, taxes, time on market, and location. We only look at new construction inside a price range for each suburb. The one in each suburb we'd go see first is the one that scored highest. We compare it to the typical new home sold in that suburb to see if it's above or below the average price per square foot. We also look at how long it's been listed, because a builder with a home listed for 4 months is usually more flexible than one with a home listed for 4 weeks.

Austin Suburbs Team Logo

Alisha & Matthew Wilson

With years of experience in both residential and investment properties, they are dedicated to helping clients navigate Austin’s thriving market.

MOVING TO the Austin TX Suburbs?

Suburbs Guide Cover

LIVING IN Austin TX

Specializing in relocation, they provide expert advice and guidance to help you find your dream home in the vibrant Austin metro market. Tune in for helpful tips, neighborhood tours, and insights on living in the Austin suburbs.

A woman adjusts her glasses in front of a split image showing suburban neighborhoods in Georgetown, Hutto, and Manor.
By Austin Suburbs Alisha & Matt • November 7, 2026
Comparing new construction in Georgetown, Hutto, and Manor TX? Explore home prices, property taxes, builders, commute times, and monthly costs before buying.
A man holding house keys smiles in front of modern homes with a sunset backdrop, promoting New Haven real estate.
By Austin Suburbs Alisha & Matt • October 31, 2026
Tour New Haven in Manor, TX, and compare DRB, Chesmar, and Weston homes from $330K to $650K. Explore builders, HOA fees, PID taxes, and lot sizes.
A woman gestures positively in front of a sign for Lagos Reserve, with a scenic view of the community in the background.
By Austin Suburbs Alisha & Matt • October 24, 2026
Buying in Lagos Reserve, Manor, TX? Compare builders, PID taxes, and annual costs to understand how each phase impacts your new home budget.